This Book Passed My “David Sedaris Meter” And That’s Why I Love It

August 26 2014
Share This Book Passed My “David Sedaris Meter” And That’s Why I Love It

I started reading Jonathan Tropper’s This Is Where I Leave You in a rush last month because I knew the movie was soon to be released (September 19, 2014). I couldn’t risk seeing any clips or movie trailers because I was worried that knowing who all of the actors playing certain characters in the book might change my reading experience.   Part of the fun of reading for me (and for many people, I think) is using imagination to create the different characters and scenes throughout the book.

I knew this book was supposed to be funny and I have always measured humorous books with something I call the David Sedaris meter. If it makes me laugh out loud while reading, it‘s a winner. I remember many years ago, shortly after I had read Me Talk Pretty One Day, I was at the Denver International airport and saw a woman laughing hysterically while reading. As I approached her, I noticed the cover of her book – Me Talk Pretty One Day. Jonathan Tropper’s novel all but busts the David Sedaris meter. I was laughing out loud many times, but also found parts of the book that made me well up with tears.

This Is Where I Leave You opens up with the dysfunctional Foxman family coming together to sit Shiva for their recently deceased father. The protagonist, Judd, has also recently discovered his wife Jen is having an affair with his boss. They’re not really a close-knit, lovey-dovey family and along the way you feel the tension and awkwardness of a group of related people forced to come together and face issues and feelings that have been built up over years. Everyone can relate in some way to the communication perils that this family encounters as they sit for Shiva.

As I made my way through the book, loving it the entire way through, I started to really get the urge to watch the movie trailer. I fell in love with all of the characters – the hot messes that they are – and my curiosity for who was cast in what role got the best of me. I watched the trailer and it only enhanced my reading experience. The casting director did a superb job. Jane Fonda playing the neurotic mother is on point, as well as Jason Bateman playing the protagonist, Judd Foxman. Tina Fey, another brilliant actor/comedienne stars as Wendy Foxman, the sister in an emotionally empty marriage. Adam Driver and Dax Shepard add to the mix and richness by playing the baby of the family and ex-high school jock.

Jonathan Tropper’s This Is Where I Leave You is an emotionally charged and deeply funny tale that will have you crying with laughter and sadness. The movie comes out on September 19, 2014. Tropper’s wit, writing style, and flawed characters have won me over for good. So much so that I’m now digging into another one of his bestsellers (also being developed into a movie), One Last Thing Before I Go.





This Is Where I Leave You
Jonathan Tropper

Simultaneously mourning the death of his father and the demise of his marriage, Judd joins his dysfunctional family as they reluctantly sit shiva and spend seven days and nights under the same roof. This Is Where I Leave You is a humorous, emotional novel about the ties that bind—whether we like it or not.

Amazon logo Audible logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Google Play logo iBooks logo


10 Books That Will Make You Feel At Home, No Matter Where You Are

By Alice Martin | November 20, 2019

6 Books to Read If You Loved “Lady Bird”

By Elizabeth Breeden | March 28, 2018

Love “This Is Us?” Here Are the 11 Books You Need to Read

By Julianna Haubner | January 3, 2018

Who Says You Can’t Go Home Again? You Can in These 5 Books

By Stu Smith | November 22, 2017

12 Literary Families to Invite Over for Thanksgiving

By Off the Shelf Staff | November 19, 2015

Piper’s Prison Book Club: 10 Books from Orange Is the New Black

By Hilary Krutt | July 28, 2015


You must be logged in to add books to your shelf.

Please log in or sign up now.