6 Cleverly Plotted Mysteries That Build in Intensity

March 7 2023
Share 6 Cleverly Plotted Mysteries That Build in Intensity

Few genres transfix me more than that of the perfectly plotted mystery. And what’s so impressive about such novels is that the author is all too aware that their book’s readership is often eager to try to complete the puzzle before the final pages (if not try to poke holes in the story line). Therefore, mystery writers must be intentional about their plotting, what it is they are willing to reveal not only to their characters but to those same readers—careful not to give too much away but also happy to reward the diligent, keen-eyed aficionados. It’s what makes a tight mystery plot such an admirable feat of storytelling.

To honor such works, I’ve compiled a list of some of the most cleverly plotted mysteries that not only hold our attention with each chapter but actually build in intensity. Get your magnifying glasses out.

The Singing Sands
by Josephine Tey & Robert Barnard

Published posthumously in 1952, THE SINGING SANDS is Josephine Tey’s final mystery featuring her beloved character Alan Grant. In it, the Scotland Yard inspector is dealing with burnout after a recent spell of overworking in which he’s suffered more than one debilitating anxiety attack. As a means of coping, Grant has taken a sick leave, deciding to take the night train to the Scottish Highlands to rest at the peaceful home of his cousin Laura. But it isn’t long before trouble finds the inspector with the discovery of a dead body aboard the train. In the newspaper that the recently deceased was reading, Grant finds an elusive poem, handwritten, about a paradise guarded by “singing sand.” And what begins as a casual inquiry—as he hopes to adhere to his doctor’s orders—soon turns into a full-blown investigation to not only unlock the key to the poem but uncover the truth about a grisly murder. Like a midnight train accelerating to its final destination, THE SINGING SANDS is the quintessential mystery that pumps the adrenaline as a legendary character gets closer to answers.

Amazon logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Google Play logo iBooks logo Kobo logo Kindle logo Bookshop logo
The Singing Sands
Josephine Tey & Robert Barnard

Bestselling author Josephine Tey’s classic final mystery featuring her best-loved character, Inspector Alan Grant, filled with “all the Tey magic and delight” and now featuring a new introduction by Robert Barnard.

On sick leave from Scotland Yard, Inspector Alan Grant is planning a quiet holiday with an old school chum to recover from overwork and mental fatigue. Traveling on the night train to Scotland, however, Grant stumbles upon a dead man and a cryptic poem about “the stones that walk” and “the singing sand,” which send him off on a fascinating search into the verse’s meaning and the identity of the deceased. Grant needs just this sort of casual inquiry to quiet his jangling nerves, despite his doctor’s orders. But what begins as a leisurely pastime eventually turns into a full-blown investigation that leads Grant to discover not only the key to the poem but the truth about a most diabolical murder.

Amazon logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Google Play logo iBooks logo Kobo logo Kindle logo Bookshop logo

MENTIONED IN:

The 12 Most Popular Books of March

By Off the Shelf Staff | March 31, 2023

6 Cleverly Plotted Mysteries That Build in Intensity

By Chris Gaudio | March 7, 2023

Close
The Shamshine Blind
by Paz Pardo

Welcome to Paz Pardo’s alternate reality where emotions have been weaponized thanks to hallucinogenic dye developed by Argentine military scientists. As a result of these “psychopigments,” the world’s cities, which were all but wiped out in a global conflict, now exist in a cycle of endless battles between the black market dealers peddling these new recreational drugs and a police force trying to contain the dealings. Kay Curtida is an agent with the Psychopigment Enforcement, working in Daly City, just outside the ruins of San Francisco. A user herself (taking Sunshine Yellow to treat her depression), Curtida is focused on small-time crooks. That is, until an old academy friend shows up with the case of a lifetime—a chance to go after the black market cartel. But the case quickly lands her in the middle of a conspiracy featuring a radical scientist, fighters from the “People’s Pigment Movement,” and an evil biopharma corporation. THE SHAMSHINE BLIND is a dazzling detective story that combines noir motifs and science fiction for a compelling mystery that delivers on all fronts.

Amazon logo Audible logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Google Play logo iBooks logo iTunes logo Kobo logo Kindle logo Bookshop logo Libro.fm logo
The Shamshine Blind
Paz Pardo

A beguiling blend of noir detective story and science fiction perfect for fans of Michael Chabon and Emily St. John Mandel, this unputdownable debut imagines a world where emotions have been weaponized, and a small-town law enforcement agent uncovers a conspiracy to take down what’s left of American democracy.

In an alternate 2009, the United States has been a second-rate power for a quarter of a century, ever since Argentina’s victory in the Falkland’s War thanks to their development of “psychopigments.” Created as weapons, these colorful chemicals can produce almost any human emotion upon contact, and they have been embraced in the US as both pharmaceutical cure-alls and popular recreational drugs. Black market traders illegally sell everything from Blackberry Purple (which causes terror) to Sunshine Yellow (which delivers happiness).

Psychopigment Enforcement Agent Kay Curtida works a beat in Daly City, just outside the ruins of San Francisco, chasing down smalltime crooks. But when an old friend shows up with a tantalizing lead on a career-making case, Curtida’s humdrum existence suddenly gets a boost. Little does she know that this case will send her down a tangled path of conspiracy and lead to an overdue reckoning with her family and with the truth of her own emotions.

Told in the voice of a funny, brooding, Latinx Sam Spade, The Shamshine Blind is “a rip-roaring beautifully crafted mash-up of cop noir, sci-fi, and alt-history that left me dazzled by its prescience and literary zing” (Leah Hampton, author of F*ckface).

Amazon logo Audible logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Google Play logo iBooks logo iTunes logo Kobo logo Kindle logo Bookshop logo Libro.fm logo

MENTIONED IN:

11 Sparkling Spring Debuts That’ll Revitalize Your TBR

By Alice Martin | March 16, 2023

6 Cleverly Plotted Mysteries That Build in Intensity

By Chris Gaudio | March 7, 2023

10 Puzzling Mysteries to Make You Feel Like an Ace Detective

By Maddie Nelson | January 24, 2023

Close
Day for Dying
by Dorothy Simpson

Called “a master of plot manipulation” by the New York Times Book Review, Dorothy Simpson’s A DAY FOR DYING does not disappoint, with an expertly crafted mystery that features Inspector Luke Thanet among an upper-middle-class cast of characters. The setting is an engagement party for Max Jeopard and Tess Sylvester. The party is already off to a rocky start when, suddenly, notorious playboy Max is found dead in the swimming pool of hosts Ralph and Marion Sylvester. What follows is a carefully paced mystery in which Thanet must unravel a stormy relationship between Max and Tess, a possible dalliance that Max may have had with the housekeeper, and the brief disappearance of the Sylvesters’ schizophrenic son, Carey, during the party. It seems that the key to understanding the full picture is Max’s charisma, which, during his work as a flashy travel writer, has been on full display in recent months. Industrious readers will be able to spot hints left by Simpson possibly before Thanet, but either way, A DAY FOR DYING is another captivating case that only becomes more dramatic as the novel reaches its explosive conclusion.

Amazon logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Google Play logo iBooks logo Kobo logo Kindle logo Bookshop logo
Day for Dying
Dorothy Simpson

When playboy Max Jeopard is killed at his own engagement party, Inspector Luke Thanet is called in to investigate and uncovers a host of suspects, including his fiancée, a jealous brother, an ex-girlfriend, and the victim’s future in-laws. “This English village ‘cozy’ goes down well” (Library Journal).

“A master at plot manipulation, Ms. Simpson cunningly strews clues right and left…The pleasure here is watching Thanet meticulously pick his way through ‘the complex web of relationships’ to arrive at an understanding of what would make a person kill for love.” —The New York Times Book Review

Amazon logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Google Play logo iBooks logo Kobo logo Kindle logo Bookshop logo

MENTIONED IN:

6 Cleverly Plotted Mysteries That Build in Intensity

By Chris Gaudio | March 7, 2023

Close
Flux
by Jinwoo Chong

Jinwoo Chong’s imaginative debut explores three different plotlines from three different characters that have lost something precious in their lives. There’s Bo, an eight-year-old who loses his mother in a traffic accident. There’s the twenty-eight-year-old Brandon, who, following the loss of his employment, manages to fall down an elevator shaft and emerge with a new job offer. And lastly, there’s Blue, a forty-eight-year-old key witness in a criminal trial, who recovers his ability to speak after being mute for most of his life. Among the timelines of characters dealing with grief, the novel includes essays from the fictional 1980s show Raider. The interconnecting theme of these three characters is that of time travel, which the author slowly unravels via connections between the television show and these protagonists. Chong writes with such deftness that readers may not realize the mystery at hand until nearly halfway through the novel. Even when they do, FLUX only picks up the pace from there—much to the delight of its readers.

Amazon logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Google Play logo iBooks logo Kobo logo Kindle logo Bookshop logo
Flux
Jinwoo Chong

Amazon logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Google Play logo iBooks logo Kobo logo Kindle logo Bookshop logo

MENTIONED IN:

6 Cleverly Plotted Mysteries That Build in Intensity

By Chris Gaudio | March 7, 2023

Close
Doctor Death
by Lene Kaaberbøl

DOCTOR DEATH follows Madeleine Karno, an ambitious young woman seeking to enter the scientific field despite the conventions of 1890s France, as she slowly unravels a murder mystery. Madeleine’s father, known as “Doctor Death,” is Varbourg’s primary pathologist and a champion of antiseptics to stop the spread of disease by bacteria. He provides Madeleine a privileged view of the world, but she’s still allowed nowhere near the autopsy table. So when a young girl, Cecile, is found dead in the snowy streets and the family refuses to let Madeleine’s father perform a postmortem, the father and daughter are left with but one single clue. And when the priest who held the vigil becomes sick and is soon murdered, Madeleine must spring into action and seek out answers. Little does she know her sleuthing will lead her down a dark, twisted path. DOCTOR DEATH is a poignant coming-of-age story and a mystery that starts on page one and only ratchets up the suspense from there.

Amazon logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Google Play logo iBooks logo Kobo logo Kindle logo Bookshop logo
Doctor Death
Lene Kaaberbøl

The critically acclaimed New York Times bestselling coauthor of The Boy in the Suitcase draws you into a “gripping” (Publishers Weekly, starred review) mystery from the very first line of this page-turning historical thriller featuring an ambitious young female detective challenging the mores of nineteenth century France.

Strong-minded and ambitious, Madeleine Karno is eager to shatter the constraints of her provincial French upbringing. She longs to become a pathologist like her father, whom she assists, but this is 1894. Autopsies are considered unseemly and ungodly, even when performed by a man.

So it’s no surprise that when seventeen-year-old Cecile Montaine is found dead in the snowy streets of Varbourg, her family will not permit a full postmortem autopsy, and Madeleine and her father are left with a single mysterious clue. Soon after, the priest who held vigil by the dead girl’s corpse is brutally murdered. The thread that connects these two events is a tangled one, and as the death toll mounts, Madeleine must seek knowledge in odd places: behind convent walls, in secret diaries, and in the yellow stare of an aging wolf.

Eloquently written and with powerful insight into human and animal nature, Doctor Death is at once a captivating mystery and a poignant coming-of-age story.

Amazon logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Google Play logo iBooks logo Kobo logo Kindle logo Bookshop logo

MENTIONED IN:

6 Cleverly Plotted Mysteries That Build in Intensity

By Chris Gaudio | March 7, 2023

Close
Ghost Image
by Ellen Crosby

Sophie Medina is a freelance photojournalist, relatively new to Washington, DC. Taking whatever work she can get, she soon finds herself at a high-society party in town where she befriends a Franciscan friar. Brother Kevin is well-known in town for his work on several “green projects” and hopes to publish a book about gardening and agriculture in the near future. It’s therefore no surprise when he asks Sophie to meet him at the Tidal Basin the next day, presumably to help lay the groundwork for such an endeavor. What is surprising is the key Brother Kevin “mistakenly” drops in the presence of Sophie during that meeting, after telling her he’s being watched. Even worse, shortly after doing so, the friar is found dead on the foot of his monastery. Sophie soon finds that the key Brother Kevin left her is to a locker where he has placed a seventeenth-century encyclopedia of plants, potentially worth millions for the answers it may unlock about an international treasure. What follows is a quick-moving mystery that takes Sophie from the US Capitol to London and, ultimately, the English countryside as she seeks a fortune…while also trying to outrun Brother Kevin’s killer. It’s a race against time and a good old-fashioned mystery that is paced to perfection and builds in intensity until the final chapters.

Amazon logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Bookshop logo
Ghost Image
Ellen Crosby

From the author of Multiple Exposure, the second “intriguing…compelling” (Publishers Weekly) novel in the thrilling Sophie Medina mystery series that features a photojournalist as she races to find an international treasure before a murderer finds her.

When freelance photojournalist Sophie Medina finds Brother Kevin Boyle, a Franciscan friar and controversial environmentalist, dead in the magnificent gardens of a Washington, DC monastery, she is sure her friend was murdered. Shortly before he died, Kevin told Sophie he was being stalked, possibly because he uncovered a botanic discovery potentially worth millions of dollars. Left with few clues to his secret, Sophie is determined to figure out who killed Kevin.

Beginning with a key that leads to a priceless original seventeenth-century encyclopedia of plants, Sophie leaps into an international treasure hunt following a trail that begins in the US Capitol and eventually leads to London and the English countryside. Before long Sophie suspects Kevin’s murderer may have been someone who knew him well. With time running out and a suspect list that includes the world’s leading botanical experts and political royalty from both sides of the Atlantic, can Sophie solve the two-hundred-year-old mystery before Kevin’s killer finds her?

A tale of greed and betrayal involving politicians, diplomats, European royalty, and a century-old monastery, Ghost Image is filled with political intrigue, history, and an international high-stakes race against a killer that will keep you guessing until the very last page.

Amazon logo Barnes & Noble logo Books a Million logo Bookshop logo

MENTIONED IN:

6 Cleverly Plotted Mysteries That Build in Intensity

By Chris Gaudio | March 7, 2023

Close

Photo credit: iStock / Andranik Hakobyan

You must be logged in to add books to your shelf.

Please log in or sign up now.