Share 9 Books I Can’t Stop Thinking About

9 Books I Can’t Stop Thinking About

Taylor Noel is a corporate marketing manager at Simon and Schuster. She loves literary fiction and memoirs, but will read any book put in her hands. Taylor shares her book obsessions on Instagram @books_with_taylor.

It’s a bad habit, but I frequently find myself staring off into space, lost in the memory of books I’ve read. Books whose plots, characters, scenes, or settings inhabit my mind long after I’ve closed the pages. Some of the books I read are for momentary pleasure or information, and some books just stick with me a little longer. Here are 9 books that I can’t stop thinking about.


The Luminaries
by Eleanor Catton
It’s a stormy night in 1866 New Zealand when Walter Moody stumbles across a secret gathering of 12 men discussing a series of inexplicable events: a wealthy man vanished, a prostitute attempted suicide, and a trunk of gold was discovered in a local drunkard’s home. The tension in the hotel bar is palpable and the scene itself is so vivid that it drifts into my mind every single week. If this masterpiece of a novel is ever turned into a movie, I could easily describe each of the required sets to the producer.
The Luminaries
Eleanor Catton

Reading XXL: 15 Extra Long Books Perfect for Extra Long Winter Nights

We like big books and we cannot lie—we buy them, we shelve them, and we stare at them, promising that someday, when we have the time, we’ll read them. Winter is the perfect season for crossing some of those wonderful doorstops off your list.

MENTIONED IN:

Readers’ Choice: October’s 10 Most Shelved Books on Off the Shelf

By Off the Shelf Staff | October 27, 2017

10 Literary Names for the Baby Name Obsessed

By Taylor Noel | October 10, 2017

9 Books I Can’t Stop Thinking About

By Taylor Noel | September 4, 2017

10 Books We Can’t (and Won’t) Stop Talking About

By Off the Shelf Staff | April 4, 2017

Off the Shelf’s 15 Favorite Book Lists from 2016

By Off the Shelf Staff | December 15, 2016

Reading XXL: 15 Extra Long Books Perfect for Extra Long Winter Nights

By Julianna Haubner | January 26, 2016

Close

A Little Life
by Hanya Yanagihara

I am absolutely haunted by Hanya Yanagihara’s emotional, heart-wrenching novel of four college classmates who move to New York seeking fame and success. As the years pass and the men all grow up and change, they remain tied together through their devotion to Jude, a brilliant, enigmatic man scarred by severe childhood trauma. I have never loved or championed a character more than I have Jude, and I will never stop thinking about his story.

Read the full review of A LITTLE LIFE.

A Little Life
Hanya Yanagihara

I’m not exaggerating at all when I say I cried for 700 pages of this 832-page masterpiece. I have never loved a character more deeply than I love Jude, the main character in this ode to male friendship, who is scarred and broken from an unspeakable trauma. Reading about Jude’s ever-changing relationships with his three best friends from college was one of the best experiences I’ve had as a reader—and certainly as a crier.

Read the review of A LITTLE LIFE.

MENTIONED IN:

The 13 Books You Need to Read to Understand Modern Relationships

By Julianna Haubner | November 9, 2017

Readers’ Choice: September’s 10 Most Shelved Books on Off the Shelf

By Off the Shelf Staff | September 29, 2017

9 Books I Can’t Stop Thinking About

By Taylor Noel | September 4, 2017

11 Books That Will Make You Ugly Cry

By Taylor Noel | June 12, 2017

9 All-Time Favorite Novels from a Bestselling Author’s Bookshelf

By Elisabeth Egan | July 12, 2016

A Beautiful, Grisly Examination of a Little Life

By Will Rhino | July 8, 2016

Close

The Lowland
by Jhumpa Lahiri

An exquisite family saga about two different brothers bound by tragedy, THE LOWLAND is vivid storytelling at its finest. Moving from the 1960s to the present and from India to America, my mind often drifts through the various and beautifully described settings as I’m falling asleep at night. I can picture Subhash in his Rhode Island home just as clearly as I can picture his brother walking to secret political meetings back home in India.

Read the full review of THE LOWLAND.

The Lowland
Jhumpa Lahiri

From the Pulitzer Prize-winning, best-selling author of "The Namesake "comes an extraordinary new novel, set in both India and America, that expands the scope and range of one of our most dazzling storytellers: a tale of two brothers bound by tragedy, a fiercely brilliant woman haunted by her past, a country torn by revolution, and a love that lasts long past death.

MENTIONED IN:

9 Books I Can’t Stop Thinking About

By Taylor Noel | September 4, 2017

Readers’ Choice: The 13 Best Books on Off the Shelf in 2017 (So Far)

By Off the Shelf Staff | March 31, 2017

The New “O” Book Club: 12 Fiction Picks from President Obama

By Julianna Haubner | January 17, 2017

Two Novels that will Redefine Your Sense of Self

By Maria Whelan | October 20, 2014

Close

Shotgun Lovesongs
by Nickolas Butler
Every time one of my friends gets engaged, which seems to be increasingly frequent these days, I think about Nickolas Butler’s SHOTGUN LOVESONGS and the four childhood friends brought together back in Little Wing, Wisconsin, for a wedding. So far, none of the weddings I’ve attended have been as exciting, stressful, and dramatic as this rich and moving book about the true meaning of adult friendship and love.
Shotgun Lovesongs
Nickolas Butler

Little Wing is a place like hundreds of others but seldom has the American heartland been so richly and accurately portrayed. For four boyhood friends brought together for a wedding, this small Wisconsin town will foster heartbreak, hope, healing, and heroism in a novel that, once read, will never be forgotten.

MENTIONED IN:

9 Books I Can’t Stop Thinking About

By Taylor Noel | September 4, 2017

12 Debut Novels You Won’t Want to Miss

By Taylor Noel | March 21, 2017

12 Favorite Novels from a Longtime Industry Insider

By Wendy Sheanin | August 20, 2015

Jump into Spring with These Book Club Picks

By Caitlin Kleinschmidt | April 21, 2015

Close

Orhan's Inheritance
by Aline Ohanesian
My dad and I discuss how remarkable ORHAN’S INHERITANCE is at least once a month, likely more often. My dad was the one who first fell in love with this novel about a young Turkish man who inherits his eccentric grandfather’s kilim rug business. As soon as he told me about it, with its striking setting and intricate web of family secrets, I was hooked. You won’t ever again be able to look at a rug without thinking of this indelible novel.
Orhan's Inheritance
Aline Ohanesian

Moving between the Armenian Genocide during the last years of the Ottoman Empire and the 1990s, ORHAN’S INHERITANCE is a lyrical and passionate novel about a young man who sets out to understand why his grandfather left his inheritance to a stranger thousands of miles away.

MENTIONED IN:

Readers’ Choice: October’s 10 Most Shelved Books on Off the Shelf

By Off the Shelf Staff | October 27, 2017

9 Books I Can’t Stop Thinking About

By Taylor Noel | September 4, 2017

14 Books by Diverse Authors You Need to Read Right Now

By Taylor Noel | May 8, 2017

Close

Grace
by Natashia Deon
I first read this debut novel on submission when I was an intern at a publishing house. I’ve been thinking about it ever since. I was obsessed, and still am. A sweeping, intergenerational saga set in the 1840s South, it follows 15-year-old Naomi—as she escapes an Alabama plantation, seeks refuge in a Georgia brothel, and falls in love with a white man—and her daughter, Josey, whose life as a slave is irrevocably changed by the Emancipation Proclamation.

MENTIONED IN:

9 Books I Can’t Stop Thinking About

By Taylor Noel | September 4, 2017

Close

'Round Midnight
by Laura McBride

A beautiful and profound novel about the interconnected lives of four women, each of whom experiences a life-changing moment at a classic Las Vegas casino nightclub, the characters in ’ROUND MIDNIGHT get into your head and stay there. These women feel more like people I know than characters on a page, and I often find myself thinking about their lives the way I think about my friends’ lives.

Read the full review of 'ROUND MIDNIGHT.

'Round Midnight
Laura McBride

MENTIONED IN:

Readers’ Choice: September’s 10 Most Shelved Books on Off the Shelf

By Off the Shelf Staff | September 29, 2017

9 Books I Can’t Stop Thinking About

By Taylor Noel | September 4, 2017

Readers’ Choice: The Top 10 Books on Off the Shelf Right Now

By Off the Shelf Staff | July 20, 2017

The New Novel That Made Me Stop Everything and Read

By Taylor Noel | June 5, 2017

Close

The Nix
by Nathan Hill
Samuel Andresen-Anderson hadn’t seen his mother in decades when she throws a stone at a prominent local politician, sparking a sensational news story and resulting in her arrest. This electric scene is burned into my brain—as is the rest of Samuel’s journey to uncover his mother’s past and long-buried secrets stretching across generations and continents.
The Nix
Nathan Hill

If your favorite character is Nancy Wheeler

If you’re a Nancy supporter at the end, you loathe a “traditional female character.” You appreciate Nancy for being a natural gunslinger, choosing the thick-haired hottie over the greasy paparazzo, and not letting her grandma-closet-raiding friend slut-shame her. THE NIX follows a whole gaggle of odd characters but centers on the mystery of a woman who is an intellectual, mother, student, daughter, protestor, lover, and—most of all—recluse.

MENTIONED IN:

How to Pack for the Perfect Bookish Vacation

By Taylor Noel | October 19, 2017

9 Books I Can’t Stop Thinking About

By Taylor Noel | September 4, 2017

11 Books You Should Read Based On Your Favorite “Stranger Things” Character

By Glommable | May 29, 2017

Close

The Paying Guests
by Sarah Waters
I didn’t think I liked THE PAYING GUESTS when I first read it. But then I couldn’t stop thinking about the gorgeous, genteel 1922 London villa in which the characters live. Then I couldn’t stop thinking about Mrs. Wray, an impoverished widow, and her spinster daughter, Frances, who have to transform their home to take in lodgers for the much-needed source of income. Then I couldn’t stop thinking about Lilian and Leonard Barber, the modern young couple taken in as lodgers. Then I couldn’t stop thinking about the passionate affair that changed everything. Then I realized how much I actually love this book.
The Paying Guests
Sarah Waters

Sarah Waters earned a reputation as one of Britain’s great writers of historical fiction, and here she delivers again. A love story, a tension-filled crime story, and a beautifully atmospheric portrait of 1920s London, this is her finest achievement yet.

MENTIONED IN:

9 Books I Can’t Stop Thinking About

By Taylor Noel | September 4, 2017

12 Contemporary British Novels We Can’t Live Without

By Caitlin Kleinschmidt | April 26, 2016

Close

Thank you for joining our email list!

If you create and Off the Shelf account, you'll be able to save books to your personal bookshelf, and be eligible for free books and other good stuff.

Click here to create your free account.

You must be logged in to add books to your shelf.

Please log in or sign up now.